Articles of Confederation, November 1777: North Carolina’s Delegates Arrive Late to the Nation’s First Constitution
Congress approved the Articles of Confederation in November 1777, but the document would not take effect until 1781. North Carolina's delegates signed months later.
- When
- 1777
- Where
- York, Pennsylvania
On November 15, 1777, the Continental Congress voted to approve a plan of union that would become the first written constitution of the United States. The members were not in Philadelphia. British troops had occupied the city since September 1777, and Congress had fled west to York, Pennsylvania, where it met in a temporary setting far from the rooms where the Declaration of Independence had been debated.
The vote was only the first step. The Articles of Confederation had to be sent to the states, approved by each legislature, and signed by delegates. That process took more than three years, and the final obstacle was not a fight over independence but a dispute over who owned the western lands.
A plan drafted in committee
Congress first appointed a committee to draft a plan of confederation in June 1776, shortly before it voted for independence. The committee had one member from each colony. Its work was led largely by John Dickinson of Pennsylvania, whose draft gave the central government limited powers and left most authority with the states.
Joseph Hewes represented North Carolina on the committee. Hewes was a merchant from Edenton who had served in Congress since 1774 and had signed the Declaration of Independence. He lost his bid for reelection in 1777 and returned to Congress in 1779.
The committee's draft was debated for more than a year. Congress made many changes, including how votes would be counted. Its final text was approved on November 15, 1777, and sent to the states.
Signing without North Carolina
Approval did not mean signatures. Congress needed the Articles to be engrossed, or written out in final form, before delegates could sign. The delegates present signed the engrossed document in Philadelphia on July 9, 1778.
North Carolina's delegates were not part of the first signing. Their names appear among those who signed on July 21, 1778, several months after the document had first been approved. Hewes was not among the signers, because he was not serving in Congress at that time. He died in Philadelphia on November 10, 1779, before the Articles took effect.
The signatures showed that Congress had a text, but they did not give it force. Under the Articles, a state's approval came from its own legislature, and a document signed in Congress had no legal power until every state had ratified it.
A long wait for ratification
Ratification moved slowly. Most states approved the Articles during 1778 and early 1779, but the process stalled once the remaining states raised questions about the western lands. Several states with claims in the West, including Virginia, Connecticut, New York, Massachusetts, and the Carolinas, had charters that seemed to reach across the Appalachians.
Maryland had no such claims. Its leaders argued that western land won in the war by all the states should belong to the confederation as a whole, and they refused to ratify until the large claimants gave up their claims. Maryland held out for roughly two years after most other states had ratified. The western land dispute was the central obstacle, though the states also disagreed about taxation and representation.
Virginia had ratified first, on December 16, 1777. Its acceptance of the Articles in January 1781, including the cession of its western claims, proved decisive. Maryland then ratified on February 2, 1781, and the Articles took effect on March 1, 1781, after the thirteenth state had approved them.
Why the delay mattered
For more than three years after the November 1777 vote, the United States ran its war and its diplomacy under a Congress whose authority rested on requests to the states rather than on enforceable law. The delay left unresolved questions about money, debt, and western settlement that would return after 1781.
The Articles did not survive the 1780s. Its weaknesses, especially the lack of power to tax, led to the Constitutional Convention of 1787, which replaced it. Still, the Articles were the first national frame of government, and the North Carolina delegates' late signatures are a reminder that the new nation was built slowly, one state at a time.
Citation information
- Article title
- Articles of Confederation, November 1777: North Carolina’s Delegates Arrive Late to the Nation’s First Constitution
- Author
- John. H.
- Website name
- North Carolina Backstory
- URL
- https://northcarolinabackstory.com/articles-of-confederation-november-1777-north-carolinas-delegates-arrive-late-to-the-nations-first-constitution/
- Original published date
- November 15, 2026
We strive for accuracy and fairness. If you see something that doesn’t look right, contact us.


